The 3DPrinter Clone Debate – Tangibot > > >


Matt Strong has invented a 3DPrinter called the TangiBot.

More precisely, he built an exact replica of the MakerBot Replicator 3DPrinter. He is attempting to raise  £315,000 (US$500,000) on Kickstarter to fund the  production of the device.

For the majority of product concepts he would be met with a swift cease-and-desist Interlectual Copywrite warning letter, but the MakerBot Replicator is OpenSource… meaning anyone can copy it and sell it.

What TangiBot lacks in design innovation it makes up for in cost. The entry-level version will sell at £755 (US$1,199) compared to  £1,134 (US$1,799) for a MakerBot Replicator.

Despite his good intentions and impressive track record, Strong is getting a lot of flak from the 3DPrinting community. Many object to the notion of using OpenSource plans to undercut the original inventor on price without changing the design.

Strong however is positive about his TangiBot: “I want to bring a low-cost machine to market that people can trust. The Replicator is the best and completely open source. I discussed the licenses with lawyers, and it’s totally legit. I want more people getting involved, designing their own tools at home, but so few people get a chance to experience 3D printing, for more people to do it, the prices have to come down. We used the same technology when I was in college. The big difference was that those printers cost $50,000 (£32,000).”

He says TangiBot is doing its part to accelerate adoption of the printers by making the machines cheaper, and eventually better.

Phillip Torrone, the creative director at AdaFruit Industries was one of the big names who weighed in on the TangiBot Kickstarter page: “Being able to copy or ‘clone’ open source and Open-Source Hardware (OSHW) is not only OK, it’s celebrated, OSHW has a goal of not only having good designs shared, but the desire to add value to the world when it’s shared and improvements are made.”

With 15 days to go and only $24,010 raised of his $500,000 goal, it seems unlikely that Strong’s TangiBot will get its kick-off, at least on Kickstarter – but whether or not the campaign succeeds, the project may serve as a turning point for OpenSource and split the community into two: One party that celebrates design achievements and interesting hacks, the another focused on supply-chain management and logistics.

Adapted from:


Comments are closed.